I recently got enmeshed in a sparring session defending accusations against George Bush’s motives in Iraq. Read that last line again, just so it’s clear: “defending accusations,” not “defending actions.” The war sucks, big time. I don’t like it, and I think it’s a terrible idea in retrospect. But go read the other post if you want to join that conversation.
So, to show how magnanimous and equitable I am, I’m going to try my hand at defending accusations against Barack Obama. That’s right. The man I’m absolutely not voting for in the upcoming election. The reason I feel the need to do this is because like I’ve been saying a lot lately, I may not like a politician’s policies, but what I dislike more is unsubstantiated sensationalism, which is so much of political media coverage.
To summarize: there are all sorts of stupid chatter about Jim Johnson, the man helping lead the VP search. I don’t know much about the man, except that he got a great deal on a mortgage from the CEO of Countrywide who happens to be his pal. Boo f-ing hoo. That’s what friends are for, I say. The CEO of Countrywide can do whatever he pleases where his business is concerned. Here’s a little golden rule of business: give your best customers the best price. I’m sure you know a bartender at a local pub who gives you a two-fer, or have an Uncle in the car business who waives a couple fees on your new ride. And if you were a multi-millionaire, you’d be pressing for the same kinds of deals, just bigger. It’s not illegal, it’s a normal cost of business, that ideally should drive additional business. Happy customers provide referrals.
My point is this: if you want to contest Mr. Johnson’s qualities as an advisor, go for it. Or if you want to trash Countrywide’s decisions in lending throughout the subprime debacle, go for it, (but please don’t forget to include the Fed in that argument, they are the ones who made it so easy to do.)
But so far, the whining about this deal is weak: the evidence (that loans at competitive rates were offered) doesn’t prove Mr. Johnson is unethical, just lucky. You better bet if my best friend was the CEO of Countrywide I’d ask for a deal! When banks are turning away 7 out of 10 deals, liquidity is dried up in the marketplace, and jumbo loans are being charged higher rates than any other product line - this is the kind of wheeling and dealing you need to do. Too bad for the naysayers, it’s not illegal. Without express knowledge of Mr. Johnson’s balance sheet and credit profile, we’re hard pressed to determine if this is a bad business decision for Countrywide and as of right now, the accusations are petty whining, amounting to crystal ball predictions.
There is too little information to accuse anyone of wrong-doing in the personal loans between Countrywide and Johnson. I await further evidence which could tip the scales, and if we find actual wrong-doing, I will personally invite you to a field day on my site, at my expense! That’s what friends are for, right? But as of right now, we should all take it easy.
Why I’ll Defend Obama – For Now…
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
9 Comments:
Good post. I definitely share understand your dislike of sensationism. Also, I am in your camp, I will definitely not be voting for Barack Obama. How do you address your friends who are fans in a generation that seems to be obsessed with the Obama-messiah?
share/understand
Brandon,
I'm in the same boat. My friends, and even some family, love Obama. I have yet to get a coherent answer as to why. The best thing you can do is always bring the conversation back to actual issues and policy (you know, what you elect presidents for) that's his biggest weakness. As far as I can tell, he's just boilerplate leftist democrat. No change. Nothing new. Old ideas in a new suit and baritone voice. Count me unimpressed.
Milena,
I agree. What's the big deal? There's more than enough about his policy positions to critique, this just distracts from any serious discussion.
@brandon henak -
I try to have rational, unemotional conversations about policies. I'll ask a lot of questions, trying to get to the heart of what someone wants, and then point out Obama is not the way to get there. But if I sense uneasiness, I back off unless someone is open to it.
I agree though, people seem to want to vote for Obama regardless of his policies. I'll have people actually say, "Policies don't matter, leadership style does." Whaaat? We are not electing a buddy or a dad! We're electing the President, whose policies can change our lives.
@Mike - great comment. I couldn't have said it better.
I just CAN'T understand how anyone would vote for a person with ties to Bush and his corrupt administration. Obama is a fresh start, a new direction -- and this country definitely needs both.
My husband has been to Iraq twice. My family suffers the consequences of Bush's bad decision. It's time to it differently. Do you realize for the past 18 year, either a Bush or a Clinton has been in office? Please, not more of the same for 4 more ...
@Anonymous - this country does need a fresh start, however I don't feel that Obama has the policies that will lead to change, despite that he may be different than the current administration does not mean he is better.
I'm sorry for your family's suffering. I truly cannot comprehend what it must be like to have to live with the threat of war, but I do not take it lightly.
@Anonymous - I entered my comment before I could express my most sincere gratitude that your husband is the caliber of man who has made the decision to sacrifice on behalf of the freedoms of our society.
Whether or not the war is the right answer, the men in service must be respected and honored.
milena,
I agree with you 100%. Many of the Obama supporters seem to think that any criticism of Obama whatsoever is somehow unfair or out of bounds. I agree that the country could use a change but Obama really hasn't put forth any new ideas that could make a big difference. Obama is not the first politician to use a vague platform with little specifics and he certainly won't be the last. Although I am not supporting him I can see how people can be attracted to him in general. The fact is that a rabid pit bull is more charming than Hillary Clinton and John McCain seems old because he is old. Some of the young bloggers seem to think that anyone older than Ashton Kutcher is too old to govern.
Keep up the good blog.
@Matt -
I'm struck by how Obama is really more of a cult of personality and most of what he has going on is bewitching, not policy.
I never even thought twice about McCain's age. Though I'm not certain I'll vote for him, age is simply not an issue for me either.
Thanks for weighing in!
Post a Comment